generic substitute for lexapro calan mg price zyprexa usa verboten cure remedies pvt ltd viagra what side effects does motilium have how much does sominex cost southwest florida alligator park revatio 40 mg tid what is the difference between aleve and ibuprofen farmaco generico al cialis how to take terramycin mg medication buy clonidine online no prescription levitra cost of aspirin in germany i pill mycelex-g website retin-a 0,05 pharmacy order genuine xeloda best price ordering levitra viagra online buy femara india buy hong kong cheap generic zyloprim alesse side effects emotional revista kosovarja 2012 low cost doxycycline what is zantac for infants used for chloromycetin prices how much does albenza cost bayer 10k run 2012 results original brahmi online tetracycline comprare zyprexa maximum daily dosage over the counter alli slimming pills celexa tablets for sale buy generic cialis online usa asda pharmacy doxycycline xenical tablets diet dilantin 100 cheap zyvox india generic promethazine w codeine is there a safe generic viagra what is mirapex tablets what is estrace cream for prescription drug celebrex arthritis relief order zyban usa today lipitor where to buy luvox pills how to get ceftin on line overnight pharmacy lasix prescription generic from aldactone desyrel ordering online pharmacy metformin without food where to buy pariet online without rx trandate online in usa where to get femara cialis us dosage for amoxicillin 875 mg zestoretic without rx buy generic keflex tetracycline mg order jagged alliance pre order steam best place to buy acticin how to buy accutane in canada costco online prescriptions canada generic available zyvox mg over counter medication same nexium overnight pharmacy liposafe acquisto decadron sicuro online buy confido tablets proscar tablets australia weight gain from seroquel xr viagra plus online forum buy generic avapro with bonus floxin generic name celexa 20 mg tablets buy arimidex pills in the mexico seroquel medication for anxiety is effexor xr generic voltaren tablets online pharmaceutical journal online buy motilium tablets ordering soft viagra online tab zyvox dose pediatrics femara over counter uk what is azulfidine oral diflucan dose for ringworm is pravachol available over the counter buy lanoxin greece is it safe to buy zoloft online what is viagra wikianswers diflucan order no prescription clonidine perth australia acquistare micardis in italia generic name for evista cheap robaxin usa prednisone 5mg tablets price side effects of atrovent nebulizer health canada mirapex effexor xr drugstore com accutane after 20 years where to buy aspirin free excedrin tamoxifen pharmacy order how do you know when you need viagra anavar pct cycle purim online uk where to buy cheap generic speman buy viagra canada paypal best erection pills available in india what works like viagra food bayer 2012 results order cipro on line uk trileptal 100 review best site to buy actoplus met cheap pletal pills lady era overnight shipping cheap differin pharmacy prices list buy alli 20 mg cialis jelly generic 2013 drugs buy cheap atarax using pay pal where to buy unisom sleeptabs most reliable place to buy actoplus met online discount himcolin mg how to by unisom online differin tablets us online buy estrace with e check order prednisolone from india without prescription canadian eulexin tablet vermox canada head office new drug better than viagra secure air pillow pool ordering phenergan shipping pure acai berry max discount can order ciplox canada daily dose cialis effectiveness side effects of decadron injection overnight pharmacy cabgolin is there a shortage of femara prescription overnight acticin online cheap albendazole 400 mg is there a generic for effexor xr venlafaxine does alavert make you gain weight isoptin 40 mg pharmacy effexor xr coupon code over the counter ventolin uk best site to purchase cialis how to buy trazodone online beat way to order zyban usual dose of pravachol is clomiphene citrate an anabolic steroids buy metformin with e check suhagra 100 mg orlistat online coupon code actonel act now program how to buy voltaren how to take nootropil mg prednisona kern pharma 10mg cheap abilify online prescription american express canada travel insurance coverage getting viagra sublingual in australia how long does levitra 10mg last low cost elavil synthetic viagra cheap genuine zoloft online actos over counter comprar fluoxetine online cheap lopid generic lariam online usa no prescription best canadian pharmacy prices buy cephalexin 250 mg 500 capsules cystone pills where to buy aromatherapy inhalers como conseguir viagra por internet buy lopid new zealand online prednisone from canada what is silagra elimite usa cvs prices generic synthroid hair loss didronel for sale philippines minocycline 100mg capsule acne allie brosh update buy dostinex lowest price can you get ciplox over the counter dulcolax online buy levothroid online pharmacy cialis sublingual sale pharmacy 5mg pastillas cytotec genericos glucotrol xl without diabetes 10mg can you get accutane uk tamoxifen dosage steroids actos lawsuit california cephalexin side effects in dogs morpheus neo red pill blue pill buy lamisil spray canada dostinex medication canada buy cipro online india ranitidine rxlist doxycycline 50 mg caps digoxin western australia cheap cefixime 400mg zestril in croatia can i buy primatene mist in canada tinidazole vs metronidazole giardiasis taking bystolic anxiety purchase mycelex-g pills ampicillin drug in mexico pharmacy manufacturer coupons for celebrex blood pressure medicine lotensin cialis professional next day delivery voltaren for sale philippines costco online promo codes canada voveran sr online usa bristol-myers squibb jobs mt. vernon in can you get high off lexapro wiki what does aspirin do to your blood tadapox online legally claritin side sleeper pillow reviews buy cialis soft pills what is mobic used for how to use motilium to increase milk dilantin overdose signs symptoms altace cough treatment buy remeron in india online buy viagra online no prescription us amlodipine 1mg canadian norvasc comprar levothroid original erythromycin drug in usa pharmacy cardizem pill shop discount code ordering cardura tadacip over the counter zofran over counter medicine pamelor tablets suhagra not generic can you order menosan adalat cc authorized generic iphone content control amitriptyline price walmart to buy voveran sr renagel (sevelamer tablets) discount didronel best viagra super prices active uk pill indian generics online ventolin missed 2 yasmin pills can we trust actonel online olanzapine paypal buy zebeta online reviews buying clonidine from canada no prescription haldol by mail suppliers of bentyl in us buy xenical orlistat us online cialis from canada low cost overnight tenormin indinavir reviews for men what are the different types of inhalers for asthma best site for citalopram buy canada no prescription for sinemet aceon pill shortage doxycycline 50mg price online drugstore usa international shipping v-gel uk brand name asthma inhalers online over the counter what is better cialis or viagra prednisolone australia pharmacy side effects of levothyroxine sodium american depakote buying valtrex without a prescription buy dutas online in usa ambien erowid trip how to get glucophage topamax pills online in the uk best site buy accutane buy amlodipine buy benzac inhaler canada discount prescriptions at cvs keflex 5mg tablets ceftin not working for sinus infection ulcer medication carafate cheap valtrex 40 mg chlamydia gonorrhea treatment men free coupon for imitrex naprosyn 500mg generic name tadalafil 20 mg acheter viagra per nachnahme instant sex drugs for women cleocin online viagra soft without prescription medication tofranil legal us medrol medication side effects nizoral now cleocin gel order canada order cystone tablets elocon buy no prescription where to get viagra singapore viagra for women online in india normal dose of flagyl for cats my mexican drugstore coupon best place buy pilex tricor in canada order aceon 2 mg generic protonix reviews online generic cialis super active reviews on trazodone 50 mg what does cymbalta do for fibromyalgia betamethasone drops nasal crestor for men in usa walgreens sale alli penegra online uk is there a generic version of differin cialis jelly to buy in england purchase benemid get norvasc toronto what does zyvox treat is the canadian healthcare system fiscally sustainable lithium price chart 2012 can you drink alcohol while doxycycline acquisto vpxl sicuro online best place to buy doxycycline online generic for aricept donepezil pastillas cialis para mujer fertomid overnight shipping cheap low cost overnight cardura cheapest orlistat xenical furosemide drug classification sertraline hydrochloride and alcohol buy levitra 5mg aciclovir tablets 800 mg dosis penicillin online uk xenical 120mg hard capsules side effects viagra plus australia pharmacy is mycelex-g a prescription drug alli weight loss prices plendil overnight delivery altace order online aspirin 100mg ec side effects desyrel to purchase without a prescription how to use suprax tulasi uses medication rhinocort online forum cod buy benadryl with visa tenormin in canada generic pills for ralista where can i buy amoxil american express merchant login us purchase prograf 1mg how much is zyban without insurance how to order propecia caverta with american express ampicillin sulbactam mechanism of action cheap generic sinequan the online drugstore viramune phenergan drug in mexico pharmacy best pharmacy to order medrol order cialis online review pharmacy mexico emsam order non generic unisom zyloprim 20mg tab antidepressant mirtazapine and alcohol street cost of promethazine aristocort ordering no prescription nymphomax on line for sale no script can you order liv 52 alli walmart canada mobic by mail hydrochlorothiazide pills where can i buy live yeast buy albendazole without prescription mail order cytotec legal buy stromectol online canada mojo pills to get erections medrol tablets 4mg triamterene shoppers drug mart buy viagra soft online from canada liquid lasix review protonix prescription dose list canadian generic drug manufacturers posso comprare cialis in farmacia senza ricetta where can i buy propranolol online without a prescription can you buy zebeta online canadian pharmacy valtrex next day delivery can you get extendaquin purchase propranolol in uk liposafe side effects uk prazosin cost advair vs flovent medicine cialis pro dosage buy canada no prescription for lasix colchicine pharmacy information himcocid billig kaufen how can you get high off of wellbutrin what is the medicine metronidazole 500mg used for where is hyaluronic acid found naturally non prescription prandin can you get lithium over the counter keflex side effects taste costco pharmacy betnovate price dilantin canadian pharmacy bactrim f para que sirve buy wild ginseng seeds where to buy periactin pharmacy buy sinequan online cheap flagyl 500 mg cost brand amoxil coupons cheap ethionamide buy online generic propecia without prescription how long does it take for tricor to work augmentin suspension pediatric dosage prevacid woldwide shipping buy lithium ion batteries australia medicine similar to abilify is meclizine sold over the counter forzest express canada buy zoloft wo a perscription cefixime 200 mg dosage atarax pills drugstore albendazole to buy in australia lowest price antabuse aristocort usa why can;t i buy alli anymore bactrim fast mexico buy femara no prescription cod best indian viagra brands what all does azithromycin treat kamagra soft on line no script alli without a perscription atarax dosage pediatric paroxetine online legally vytorin discount can i buy a ventolin inhaler buy xenical cheapest sale buy cheap zebeta micardis generic date non generic cheap amitriptyline purchasing lipothin online uk buy generic cipro online with prescription benzac australia price fast prograf deleviery clopidogrel bisulfate 75 mg side effects ephedraxin suppliers overseas quick slim acai reviews compazine dosage migraine buy canada no prescription for nolvadex ayurslim dosage instructions can order capoten canada cymbalta overnight delivery mg albendazole results forum lowest priced prometrium gabapentin buy american generic cialis how old are s club juniors now asacol pharmacy coupons amitriptyline 150mg no prescription mastercard pink lortab 7.5 coversyl drugs com combination zyban order by phone where to buy amaryllis plant pharmacy drugs in mexico flonase next day shipping side effects of cleocin hcl female viagra samples buy dulcolax tablets cheap advair diskus india find all complaints of northwest pharmacy in canada best place to buy pct online lotensin limited india sildenafil citrate china viagra de 100 mg order tofranil medication by mail crestor australia side effects where to buy acai lipo in australia trental and weight gain can you only get shallaki on prescription metformin er side effects weight gain para q se usa nexium rumalaya cost without insurance cafergot for men sale in uk can famvir get you high kamagra billig kaufen Purchase abilify 4mg canada what is medrol cialis professional generic 2013 drugs diprosone lotion side effects order atrovent pill metoclopramide 10 mg price fucidin ointment generic name minocin drug induced lupus zanaflex online no prescription voltaren from new zealand best generic nizoral review cialis in usa kaufen cialis mail how to buy effexor xr generic pills for zofran alli discount code buy kamagra online uk jelly 100mg valtrex free shipping where can i get protonix pills beat way to order endep levitras walmart pharmacy atorvastatin allegra cheap uk flagyl side effects in puppies online pharmacy no prescription needed doxycycline viagra jelly without prescription pills do i need a prescription for imuran finax cost canadian muscle enhancement drugs kamagra buy online ireland can you buy prescription cheap celadrin cod brand kamagra gold buy reviews on nolvadex is it illegal to order generic phenergan reviews forum cialis online generic diclofenac sodium ophthalmic the online drugstore pyridium do you need rx renagel pfizer viagra discount card 100mg what is better propecia or rogaine ciprobay xr and alcohol reviews on snovitra super power apcalis sx 50mg tablets cheap generic viagra pills buy plendil 20 tenormin max dose no prescription buy levaquin online discount prinivil otc what is keppra xr used for how to get a cialis prescription online bula do reme'dio sertralina low cost online buy avalide effexor xr spain over counter viagra australia buy zestril perth australia quiero comprar imitrex glucophage sr spc can you buy levitra plus in ireland canadian fda approved uses for viagra brand cialis us pharmacy fluoxetine fast mexico deltasone online forum prescription drugstore buy gabapentin for dogs uk where to buy mentat ds syrup ointment the chepest trial erection packs 1 maxalt suppliers overseas depakote dosage depression oral estrace side effects lopid without insurance zoloft medication on line citalopram buy online uk can order amitriptyline online buy seroflo hong kong 50mcg asthalin lasix dosage iv push can you buy differin over the counter little blue pill abg 100 amaryl where can i get some levitra super active cost of januvia 25 mg rumalaya forte online order hyzaar complications cleocin 300 mg cost where to buy bystolic (nebivolol) levitra canada with overnight service online pharmacy uk floxin side effects of cyproheptadine hydrochloride where can i get some exelon augmentin cost at walmart is ceftin good for strep throat can i get zyban in the nhs generic finax no prescription brand viagra express canada buy aciclovir mg online requip over counter letrozole dosage for breast cancer actavis prometh with codeine cough syrup for sale domperidone australia evista with no perscription can men take hydroxycut max women cheapest place to buy doxycycline liquid nolvadex sale gonorrhea cipro dosage best place to buy serpina in usa side effects of carafate tablets best place to buy xenical online buy zyvox 80 mg online comprar flonase online where is alli mavi umut tu"rku" evi cialis a vendre montreal allopurinol 300 mg side effects order midamor tablets generic cialis usa pharmacy alesse for sale usa buy brafix cheap buy zithromax quick annual sales generic toprol xl z pack dosage 500 mg normal dosage of strattera brand levitra for sale order bactrim pill otc prevacid in canada cheapest place to buy propecia buy nizoral shampoo 1 buy lozol singapore where to buy micardis hct reminyl prices proventil tablets for sale where flagyl er buy eulexin online at canada pharmacy cfc free asthma inhalers oder mg tablets of topamax pharmacy mexico ginseng best online pharmacy generic trimox buy seroquel pills online ponstel where can i buy it zenegra without insurance tegretol online forum buy nitrofurantoin in singapore buy over the counter torsemide online astelin nasal spray coupons buy vantin line buy retino-a cream 0,05 greece pastillas para la ereccion masculina usa betapace uk brand name fertomid generic release date zofran australia pharmacy how to purchase antivert online danazol online erectile dysfunction treatment canada propranolol dosage forms overnightpharmacy4u review buy kamagra india online pharmacy evecare without prescription canada does mercaptopurine cause hair loss aristocort generic reviews where to buy tetracycline online overnight reglan online overnight shipping what is neurontin 100mg used for no prescription pharmacy turkey levitra professional kaufen effexor xr reviews and dosage buy advair diskus online no prescription united states quibron-t generic reviews maximum protonix dosage better than female cialis furosemide online dictionary generic imitrex in usa how to get cheap car insurance organic pharmacy detox prevacid solutab generic equivalent what is actoplus met used for bactroban 2 ointment cost decadron price india exelon shortage abc online pharmacy discount

Is a Secular System Right for Egypt?

This month, as reported by Reuters, the Egyptian government announced new measures to increase “supervision over all Egypt's mosques so that they do not fall into the hands of extremists and the unqualified.” The removal of thousands of clerics—numbering 12,000, according to the government’s statement—comes in the context of the ongoing struggle between the Muslim Brotherhood and the military-backed regime. 

Outside observers of this struggle may be tempted to frame it as a contest between an Islamist theocracy and a secular state, albeit an alarmingly iron-fisted one. However, as revealed in a discussion of the future of Egyptian democracy by academics, journalists, and activists convened at The Immanent Frame, the situation is far more complex. 

While the government’s recent measures will strike many as draconian, they’re unfolding within an environment of established law, as presented in a fine-grained analysis by Amr Ezzat, a journalist and researcher on religious freedom with the Cairo-based Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights. By law, all sermons, religious instruction, and charitable activities taking place in and around the country’s mosques are subject to the oversight of the Ministry of Endowments, which seeks compliance with a “moderate” Sunni conception of the faith as represented by the intellectual orthodoxy of al-Azhar.


In his contribution to the Immanent Frame conversation, Georgetown professor of Islamic history John Voll argues that while the military regime has opposed Brotherhood domination, the alternative it supports is not secularism. Instead, he writes, the system “is one of state control over religious institutions, rather than separation of church and state.” 

To present this second contrast with secularism, Voll revives a colorful old term for the state domination of religion: caesaropapism, from the Latin and Italian for emperor and pope, respectively. This theory of the relationship between religion and state has its roots in the Roman imperial tradition, dating to Augustus, in which a single ruler acted as high priest and supreme civil authority at once—the pontifex maximus.

Rachel Scott, a professor of Islamic Studies at Virginia Tech, challenges the "religious-secular binary" itself, connecting it with what William Cavanaugh has called “the myth of religious violence,” or the assumption that religion is “inherently authoritarian, divisive, and predisposed to irrational violence.” Abandoning this assumption, she believes, will help us to see that “Western-style secularism is a contingent and local set of social arrangements and not a universal solution.”

Egyptian society would benefit, Scott asserts, from eschewing "a conceptual frame that constructs the constitution and political actors as either secular or religious," and talking instead of "an opposition between authoritarian and non-authoritarian institutions." Or, in the spirit of the 2011 revolution, "institutions and procedures that support justice and human dignity, and those that do not.” 

For his part, Ezzat sees the present legal structures as vestiges of the Ottoman model of an Islamic caliphate, the “state of Muslims” in which the congregation of Muslims was conceived as a unitary and uniform politico-religious entity. The alternative, he says, “is to abandon the Muslim state for a modern nation-state that fully embraces the concept of citizenship, which would entail the disappearance of political authority over religious affairs and open the door to religious freedom.” 

That sounds like secularism to me.

Is secularism a viable ideal for the current Egyptian context? And what would it mean for the future of religious participation in politics? In the coming weeks, I will take to this space to explore these questions.

RD contributing editor Austin Dacey will be writing a series of posts and essays in the coming months as part of a joint project between The Immanent Frame and Religion Dispatches made possible by the generosity of the Luce Foundation.

 Source: USC Annenberg