lisinopril order buy digoxin xr without prescription betnovate skin cream reviews get geriforte toronto anti nausea medicine zofran low betnovate skin redness online viagra in canada arthrotec side effects long term use can you take yasmin daily can i make nexium motrin 40 mg 1 ml beat way to order topamax gyne-lotrimin delivery london which is better zyban or champix avodart online legally buy bupropion in india online what is calcium carbonate used for best place to buy advair diskus in australia atorlip 20 para que sirve what are the side effects of taking valtrex while pregnant canadian pharmacy online moduretic side effects of nexium in babies what is compazine used to treat does herbal viagra really work yagara usa cvs prices donde puedo comprar orlistat parlodel prices usa himplasia generic wikipedia drugs pariet delivery london buy doxazosin visa fucidin ointment review purchase emsam online valtrex price comparison where zyrtec endep perth australia medicine augmentin 625 toradol without a prescription buspar for purchase skipping sugar pills levlen ed order levaquin 750 mg chlamydia in mouth pics india wellbutrin price can i take prilosec 20 mg twice a day buy seroquel online canada fast accutane delivery floxin prices usa premarin woldwide shipping can buy ranitidine online risperdal usa sale forzest sale online silagra side effects uk purchase vytorin cheap can you buy cialis sublingual over the counter in germany acai berry cost in india coreg shopping accutane best price masque visage brahmi depakote drugstore safe place order glucophage pictures of zantac pills order cialis sublingual 120 mg depakote noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy online pharmacy uk diamox buy pilex paypal indian pharmacy terramycin youtube we are young order nexium 40 mg online zebeta low dose birth control actos comunicativos orales where to purchase minomycin most reputable online canadian pharmacy celexa brand order order effexor xr non prescription strattera pharmacy lamisil pills cost depo medrol shortage norvasc amlodipine besylate buyers of accutane canada xalatan in croatia diflucan 150 capsules legal buy trandate online canada top 10 drug sales get detrol toronto where can i purchase septilin long term side effects of lithium overdose what does the pill diclofenac do how do i get a prescription without insurance what is calcium carbonate used for in food where to buy allegra 80 mg buy nexium with paypal is it illegal to order generic eldepryl top 10 best pills to get high off order combivent from usa without prescription what is lasix used for in horse racing drugs from india price controls spc lisinopril tablets chloromycetin with no rx buy lamictal with no rx why is there a shortage of metoclopramide nizagara not generic what is the correct dose of prednisone for poison ivy singulair ordering no prescription canadian medicine history robaxin no prescription reviews can i order desyrel no prescription in the usa free viagra trial offer nitroglycerin explosion youtube can you buy shallaki over the counter in germany levitra preisvergleich generika benadryl dose for cats buying fluoxetine from canada no prescription discount pilex mg metoclopramide dose for cats what drug category is dulcolax cost of cialis daily use nexium 20mg capsule buy pravachol astrailia lexapro cost assistance accutane side effects post treatment accutane online no prescription medication zenegra for dogs buy atacand pills side effects buy online seroquel generic voltaren generic uk order codeine syrup online lady era rx long time side effects methotrexate bactroban australia pharmacy terramycin pharmacy order compazine iv half life online generic aristocort famvir italiano obat voltaren untuk chlamydia nhs symptoms what herb is like lexapro cheap stromectol ivermectin buy stromectal yagara next day shipping 20 order accutane 20mg med cab retino-a cream 0,05 generic furosemide buy canada lopressor for sale uk cipla pharma company product cvs pharmacy online account terramycin prescription coupon diflucan pharmacy price can u get clomid over counter where to buy tretinoin 0,025 in canada safely legitimate online no prescription pharmacies silagra without prescription miami mail order generic innopran xl what is the generic drug for benicar hct no rx nizoral online ampicillin dose neonate voltaren gel price what does nizoral cream treat is serevent legal in uk buy abilify 4mg online cipro flagyl interaction can order caverta online prednisolone for purchase pfizer authorized generic lipitor drug coupons for viagra uk pharmacies online that sell tamoxifen olanzapine 100 review generic lithium no prescription liquid atorlip-5 review acyclovir cream for shingles aap ki adalat indiatv safemeds viagra coupon code clomiphene dosage pct augmentin no rx what doses does fluoxetine come in renagel shop net hydrea dose plendil online price amoxicillin uses what does female viagra look like cheapest bactroban in the uk advair diskus in canada legal buy plavix online canada can i get radio 5 live on my iphone metformin dose uk buy lady era 100mg online lamisil 5mg tablets drugstore cheap hyzaar online brand amoxil without prescriptions inhouse pharmacy reviews where can i buy cialis super active in canada provera pills drugstore how to import tofranil pamelor online in us common side effects of minocin combivent india buy actos with drugs discount canadian pharmacy avalide also known ceftin pharmacies in best place to buy ampicillin online canadian pharmacy kamagra chewable buy glucotrol xl with visa very cheap celebrex buy voltaren gel otc nexium cause weight gain canadian online pharmacies no prescriptions canada pharmacy 24 hour drug store phenergan canada no prescription wellbutrin rx assistance astelin buy on line where to buy levitra in canada online retin-a 0,05 from usa compazine tablets 150 mg pravachol on line no script best place buy tricor lotrisone from mexico buy alphagan us eye drops brimonidine where to penegra generic serophene us cheap genuine mestinon online buy clozaril tablets us best medication ringworm scalp cheapest erexin-v buy phenergan 40 robaxin without prescriptions how long does it take for lamictal to take effect fallout 3 where to find mentats citalopram hbr 10 mg tablet viagra usa drugstore can buy phenamax online ordering norvasc usa purchase star alliance lounge access slimming tablets that work uk calan uk boots online pharmacy usa international shipping mirapex in croatia nitroglycerin dosage forms in egypt comprar dutas en argentina discount canadian pharmacy fincar cipro for sale hyzaar blood pressure medication where can i buy antivert stromectol 10 mg buy cleocin gel online reviews minipress delivery diskus sale discount cheapest advair zyvox sales 2011 bupropion shoppers drug mart metformin and clomid 100mg success stories nootropil 800 mg 30 film tablet fiyat? buy trileptal online overnight accutane generic usa zestril from usa hctz 25mg hydrochlorothiazide medication colchicine mexico no prescription without script buy allopurinol online pharmacy buy orlistat without ponstel online usa no prescription purchase vpxl pills warfarin interactions with herbs buy allergy order cheap atarax where can i get eurax no prescription super active plus buy levitra online american express platinum business card canada robaxin discount code what does claritin look like japanese viagra professional safe site to buy nolvadex use fluconazole pregnancy buy casodex greece femcare delivery side effects enhancement drugs cefixime mist canada what is astelin nasal spray used for florinef in the uk xenical prix en pharmacie abana tablets retin-a 0,05 max dose amoxicillin trihydrate rxlist buying drugs in london tadalafil 5 mg india what is children;s motrin used for order viagra online canadian pharmacy methotrexate drug canadian pharmacy side effects prednisone steroids women buy offers tetracycline click here purchase zoloft online no prescription mail order generic serophene bactroban medication order shallaki to buy in england costco pharmacy lithium price buying citalopram 10mg sale arimidex generic ditropan xl aricept where to get canada pharmacies online that sell metformin 100 mg amitriptyline zyloprim italiano haridra non perscription countries zovirax medication order indocin tablets us online difference between renvela and renagel forum buy prednisolone online day delivery viagra online europa what is the usual dosage for synthroid legal buy calan online canada buy xenical tablets mail order pharmacy technician salary elimite for sale philippines what is acticin used to treat family meds online pharmacy fucidin without prescription miami altace max dosage celadrin uk brand name costco watford jobs erythromycin on line in the uk cleocin italiano methotrexate uk brand name acquistare zyrtec in italia buy vasotec 100mg online max zofran dose tri levlen 28 tribal wars stats uk is generic rogaine 2 available in usa over the counter zantac for children elavil 10 mg amitriptyline hcl can buy cipro online vytorin 100 review can you order hytrin cialis prescribing information valtrex pills best accutane prices purchase fml forte ed pills australia hydrochlorothiazide-triamterene mechanism of action mentax shopping get epivir-hbv las vegas canadian pharmacy online fluoxetine no prescription nexium store generic affordable how to take nitroglycerin tablets buy brafix pills buy dilantin cheap there generic rhinocort seroflo canada head office roche xenical colombia price of viagra in nigeria side effects of levitra and alcohol haridra online now click here medicine cafergot side effects of propranolol use lasix alternative medicine what is decadron made of maxalt canada prices hoodia p57 reviews side effects purchase cipro 500 mg online legit place to buy accutane online mail order kamagra tretinoin 0,025 prescription coupon us pharmacies online that sell prilosec omnicef online no prescription different types of asthma inhalers buy anafranil usa overnight delivery buy floxin drug double dose alavert where to buy alli decided can topamax pills be split buy artane online with mastercard nitroglycerin tablets recreational use aciphex tablets purchase on line discount order buy aceon lov cost furosemide costo de femara en mexico zoloft weight gain weight loss bystolic medication cost cheap ciales cost of plavix at costco biaxin without rx discount canadian pharmacy lithium pfizer viagra coupon nach baliye 5 17th march 2013 desi tashan levothroid side effects in men best place to buy brand viagra doxycycline (many brand names and generic) compare prices tadalis sx ordering zenegra sample diabecon dose buying lopressor in manchester buy glycomet uk canada drugs pravachol with prescription overnight meds-usa doxycycl hyc 100mg used for voltaren emulgel 100g prices list of side effects of champix med cab retino-a cream 0,025 zovirax medicine side effects levitra super active buy uk zoloft for sale no prescription side effects of phenergan iv buy generic betnovate are there any over the counter antibiotics for uti brafix online legally buy betamethasone drops generic fucidin paypal pilex to buy in australia buy lexapro in canada suhagra prescription buy provera lowest price celexa lexapro substitute how to buy yasmin birth control phenergan for kids sleep buy $30 provera online side effects of himalaya shatavari what is casodex medication cheap rogaine 5 sale uk buy tretinoin 0 05 mg sildenafil citrate 100mg for sale cheap cialis not generic zetia drugstore how much is allopurinol tablets alli 120 mg dose how long do nizoral tablets take to work lithium orotate side effects weight gain research grade evecare duphalac price india atarax tablets uk ranitidine from canada nifedipine tablets 10mg propranolol pharmacy order what is lioresal baclofen endep in croatia buy cephalexin no prescription fast delivery styplon delivery uk free coupon for evecare us online pharmacy no prescription alli how to order adalat buy allegra d 24 hour from canada revia canada overnight delivery aciclovir not generic trandate in the uk biaxin uk online amantadine for sale buy diclofenac gel online no prescription us albendazole in italia stromectol 5mg tablets buy effexor xr without prescription generic for alphagan eye drops ciprobay 1000mg side effects biografia alli simpson wikipedia over the counter cipro xr best price for real fincar buy flonase greece betapace 40 mg dose lipitor for sale australia buy parietaria officinalis buy avalide canada can u order clomid online buy viagra now is bactroban ointment prescription only buy alavert in india online walmart medical expense report pharmacy orlistat generico efectivo generic carbozyne safe when should clomid dose be increased cheapest noroxin viagra online pay by american express is voltaren emulgel a prescription drug how much does cialis daily use cost 20mg list top pharmaceutical companies india actos phone orders buy oxytetracycline uk no prescription hoodia sale what is venlor medication for generico do moduretic what is coreg cr for prescription proscar pariet generic cheap costs levaquin drug canadian pharmacy buy promethazine with codeine syrup with no prescription anxiety medication effexor xr lanoxin without prescription canada viagra shoppers drug mart costco pharmacy fosamax price vasotec 5 mg buy diclofenac capsules cheap kamagra uk next day delivery generic generic name for viagra ibepokin buy lithium batteries for cars lexapro 5mg for anxiety buy shuddha guggulu cheap where to purchase viagra safely online buy benadryl from mexico online order minocin 50mg hyzaar online sales what does relafen cost cheap generic consult venlor online lithium price history chart side effects of zaditor eye drops how much will geriforte syrup cost canadian lexapro drugs isoniazid uk buy resources for cialis super active what is trileptal drugs sumycin spain motilium noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy zovirax tablets no prescription where can i buy birth control pill comprar atacand portugal can you use bactrim ds for sinus infection diclofenac dose for rats lamisil 250 mg tablet fiyat? calan from canadian pharmacy buy anafranil 200 starlix online topamax withdrawal anxiety sandoz pramipexole side effects buy rythmol sr alli cvs pharmacy buy sildenafil pills what is celebrex taken for advair diskus in croatia coumadin 5 mg prices purchase propecia in uk artane cost without insurance mail-order zestoretic

Chaplaincy program back in the dock of the High Court

Ron Williams is the father of four children at Darling Heights State School in Toowoomba, Queensland. Like many other schools, it has a chaplain funded by the federal government. Williams took objection to this, saying taxpayers should not pay for a religious position in a state school.

Williams has taken the remarkable step of fighting for his beliefs all the way to the High Court. On Monday, his legal team will argue before the court that the chaplaincy scheme is unconstitutional.

The case is the most anticipated of the year. If Williams succeeds, the court may not only strike down the chaplaincy scheme, but also hundreds of other federal programs worth billions of dollars. The result could rewrite the book on how the Commonwealth and the states spend public money.

The battle against the chaplaincy program has spanned several years. Williams first challenged the scheme in the High Court in 2010. He argued then that the program breached the separation of church and state and, in particular, section 116 of the constitution which says "no religious test shall be required as a qualification for any office or public trust under the Commonwealth". This argument failed.


A second argument won him the day. He said the federal government lacked the power to spend money on the chaplaincy scheme because the scheme lay outside of its power. Williams successfully challenged the long-standing assumption that the federal government can spend taxpayers’ money without the specific support of Parliament on whatever program it wishes.

In ruling this way, the High Court delivered a surprising new limit on federal power. It emphasised what many had forgotten – that the nation was not created with a dominant Commonwealth in mind, but as "a truly federal government". The court also reasserted the principle that governments can spend money only with parliamentary approval.

These ideas were used to overturn the chaplaincy program, and had much wider implications. In the decision’s aftermath, then attorney-general Nicola Roxon identified 427 programs as lacking any visible constitutional support. They amounted to as much as $37 billion a year, or 10 per cent of all federal expenditure.

The federal funding programs under threat ranged from pork-barrelling to good public policy. They included drought assistance and disaster relief, support to the car industry, numerous local initiatives, indigenous education and employment, laptops in schools, refugee support schemes, community policing, climate change research and support for children with disabilities.

There was no doubt the Commonwealth could continue to fund these activities if it did so via the states. This is permitted by section 96 of the constitution. However,involving the states in these programs would have meant sharing some of the responsibility and political benefits. As a result, the federal government decided to shore up its position in a different way.

Within a week of Williams’ High Court victory, a law was rushed through both houses of Federal Parliament. It gave the stamp of approval to all these funding schemes in one big block. One such scheme rescued from oblivion was the chaplaincy program.

This paved the way for Williams’ second foray into the High Court. He is now once again challenging the chaplaincy program, and in doing so the federal government's entire rescue package. The significance of the case is reflected in the fact that every state will attend the court to put their position.

Williams will again argue that the federal government lacks the power to fund chaplaincy services in state schools. He will also say the special law passed by Parliament to give legislative backing to this and other schemes is either ineffective or unconstitutional.

The federal government by contrast is arguing that its rescue package is valid. It is also taking the rare step of asking the High Court to declare that its earlier decision in favour of Williams was wrongly decided.

There is a good chance the challenger will again emerge victorious. Strong doubts were expressed about the validity of the rescue law at the time it was passed. The doubters included Senator George Brandis, who said from opposition that he was "far from satisfied" that the fix "is effective to satisfy the constitutional lacuna which the High Court identified".

Brandis now finds himself in the position of Attorney-General, and so must defend the scheme in court. He can only hope that his prediction proves ill-founded, or he will face a big headache. A second loss in the High Court may mean that there is no easy fix for a range of federal funding programs, many of which are important to local communities and politically popular.

Such a result may require a rethink of how the federal government spends public money. One option is for it to cease several of its funding programs. An alternative would be to direct money to the states to spend on its behalf. Neither choice would be palatable for it.

George Williams is the Anthony Mason professor of law at the University of NSW.

Source: The Age