what types of colchicine are there cipro delivery minocin brand positioning finpecia discount drugstore what is saw palmetto called in telugu buy augmentin cheap antibiotic drug mobic purchase cheap lexapro 20mg online v-gel maximum dosage med cab cialis jelly buspar legal us cheap atorlip-10 famvir recommended dosage brand cialis from mexico how much is mircette tablets switching from zoloft to effexor erythromycin without prescription canada what is sildenafil andros post cycle therapy clonidine is metronidazole cream over the counter air max 1 leopard print uk best anti-depression medication for men terramycin drugstore.com how much is luvox tablets why vermox discontinued purchase topical erythromycin what does leukeran proscar generic release date i pill benfotiamine website elocon cream buy uk buying famvir online lariam usa cvs prices diabecon drugstore.com getting advair diskus in australia evecare for sale uk ordering promethazine ordering amaryl no prescription what is piroxicam 20 mg atrovent roche precio argentina alavert to buy in england endep online pharmacy uk alesse low dose wyeth hydrochlorothiazide tablets used for meijer pharmacy metformin nirvana testo lithium italiano mail-order cialis super active zanaflex prescription assistance canada pharmacy differin levothyroxine dosage albendazole treatment for neurocysticercosis where can i order propranolol order actoplus met 11 mg brand eldepryl for sale luvox dosage range ventolin perth australia get pain pills er cialis professional 100 review daily cialis free sample topamax diet pills best viagra super active prices cialis 100mg simvastatin and diltiazem interaction toradol dosage children differin delivery london prednisone side effects in women ditropan 5 mg dosage buy retin a 0 025 generic buy hydrochlorothiazide with paypal generic and brand name for aspirin where to buy inderal drugs online abilify 15 mg tablet picture can u buy xenical over counter there generic sinemet acheter ginseng ame'ricain cytoxan uk buy emsam shortage 2012 cipro for overseas travel non persciption zyloprim allegra 30 mg orally disintegrating tablets buy tramadol cod next day delivery order erection packs 1 vardenafil levitra online pharmacy uk singulair non prescription clomid pharmacy dapoxetine over the couter buy percocet no prescription needed use avodart coupon online to buy yasmin in uk phone in order for medrol buy arimidex australia buy prinivil in ireland what does serevent look like can order carafate online atarax for anxiety disorder online pharmacy uk brand advair diskus aristocort prices cvs cialis or viagra with alcohol acheter valtrex pas cher buy bactrim paypal women viagra protonix 40 mg bid generic name for indocin medrol ivf success acquisto bupron sr sicuro online calan catch can for sale side effects of voltaren emulgel what is rogaine 2 pills used for metronidazole dosage for cats pill rx health trazodone products order elocon cream 0.1 prescription actonel canada head office united states pharmacy selling cialis online generic actonel no prescription cuvarlix review lipitor commercial actor ampicillin sodium salt sigma where can i buy liquid clomid canada drugs minocycline with prescription where to buy aciclovir pharmacy valtrex supplier in uk prescription drugs without a prescription usa genuine zebeta 100mg cordarone comprare overseas pharmacy no prescription cozaar hydromorphone hydrochloride what is actonel medicine elocon cream sale trazodone hydrochloride dosage sildenafilo cinfa 50 mg precio fastest requip uk delivery buy ortho tri cyclen online zestoretic pharmacy prices list noroxin cmi depakote generic price online pharmacy no prescription needed compazine wellbutrin sr order online no prescription kamagra (sildenafil citrate) uk generic flagyl 400 mg actonel 150 mg tablet order levlen online with visa asacol generic launch buying diakof from canada no prescription biaxin order by phone how to take flovent buy generic tetracycline online with prescription comprar raiz ginseng rojo nizoral medication order crestor online canadian pharmacy zyloprim cost comparison success rate of clomid in women over 40 order accutane cheap buy coumadin in australia prednisone medrol dose pack dosage arimidex canadian source generic lamisil india how to get floxin on line levitra cialis and viagra comparison metformin without a prescription from uk yasmin nowe clozaril discounts codes cephalexin breastfeeding kellymom prescription free viagra london over the counter aspirin products cheapest drug innopran xl can get clomid prescription side effects of diltiazem hcl 120mg onde comprar xeloda where buy viagra london eltroxin tablets uk canada viagra buy prednisone withdrawal muscle pain where can i buy propecia yahoo Purchase flagyl 500mg online half price clomid where to get clomid privately purinethol without a prescription fastest prometrium uk delivery depakote in italia essential tremor propranolol dose prevacid over counter same prescription mentat ds syrup where can i buy it capoten medication where to buy elavil over counter alli sale gsk what is trazodone medication purchase abilify 20mg online what is cleocin gel used for buy wellbutrin sr cheap doxycycline prices cvs buy chloroquine in usa para que sirve redustat 120 mg florinef refills ditropan 5mg tablets best generic viagra review where to purchase colchicine without lov cost colospa side effects of luvox in men buy genuine decadron uk glucophage vs generic metformin is there withdrawal from trazodone treatment caverta dosage recommended femara price generic astelin uk paypal crestor medication side effects com augmentin now prescription painkillers without aspirin buy silagra 20 is trazodone better than seroquel what is the drug zoloft used for shampoo better than nizoral order tricor 48 mg aleve online shipping propecia 5mg vs 1mg what is the mechanism of action for lopressor viagra and poppers at the same time prilosec wildberry ingredients is it safe to order wellbutrin purchase vermox on line in uk viagra prescription drug canada erythroped erythromycin medicine reglan dose for nausea antabuse drugstore com over the counter allegra dosage is there a generic for maxalt-mlt pill rx health zovirax products viagra and cialis at the same time triamcinolone acetonide cream usp 0.1 urispas lawsuit canada alesse missed 2 pills minocycline capsules reviews best price for digoxin what class of drugs is promethazine doxycycline medicine online tinidazole safe during pregnancy american cystone lb agar ampicillin-100 plates fucidin price in india western drug dramamine yasmin birth control reviews 2012 what types of cialis soft are there side effects of allopurinol zyloprim how to by famvir online prednisone withdrawal in dogs symptoms reviews on minocycline retin a uk online viagra sublingual phone orders prilosec online printable coupons buy vpxl in australia trusted online pharmacy xanax what types of skelaxin are there cialis generic sarasota prescriptions assistance programs advair diskus inhalation powder strattera 100 mg dosage alesse birth control lawsuits can i get blopress how long does it take for accutane to clear up acne where isoniazid indocin 100mg tablet orlistat with paypal payment cheap exelon 1.5 mg india can we trust zetia online i pill cholestoplex website delivery cheap antabuse prescription uk when is the best time to start taking clomid do i need a prescription for kamagra chewable percentage men have side effects propecia zetia prescription assistance discount code for zyloprim med cab indinavir why is colcrys better than colchicine what does cipro hc otic do what is grifulvin v micro 500 lamisil not generic glucophage online order shallaki online bestellen uk version of viagra professional how do i buy things on ebay with paypal baytril noah compendium zantac online usa buy vasodilan online tadalis sx sold over counter generic propecia in canada suhagra or sildenafil side effects more risperdal low dose for depression over counter rogaine 5 medicine advair diskus fluticasone and salmeterol lantus solostar needles prices viagra professional visa buying asacol for dogs research grade zofran what is the best over the counter antibiotic for dogs bentyl in usa ayurslim costco viagra professional overseas compare prices wellbutrin sr alli 120 count best price colospa tablets acai architects florida buy amoxil online no prescription canada pain meds for arthritis my canadian pharmacy order where is a trusted place to buy viagra lov cost deltasone how long does it take to adjust to norvasc nexium buy mexico viagra plus generic cialis cymbalta coupons printable long term side effects of taking doxycycline bactrim ds 800-160 mg tablets buy cephalexin 500mg cap buy tetracycline tablets us which uk site to buy lasix taking too much synthroid side effects cartoon network games ben 1000 buy generic tetracycline no prescription price discounts low betnovate prescription zofran reviews gastroenteritis blue oval pill vgr 100 buy lantus solostar online canada acyclovir side effects in infants how long does it take to become a pharmacy technician buy voveran sr for daily use motrin reviews and dosage man vs food guy healthy where can i buy lipitor without a prescription where can i buy sildenafil citrate over the counter best place to buy live fish online uk pharmacies online that sell differin gabapentin tablets 600mg atacand 16 mg 28 tablet ilac, kamagra gold barato can buy cialis super active online cheap isoptin 40 mg online pharmacy uk shuddha guggulu zyprexa price increase top 10 online vpxl sites aurochem india buy maximum zanaflex dose buy cheap trimox using pay pal buy sumycin uk cheapest liquid chloromycetin review 1 pound fish man bbc vasotec dosage instructions side effects of compounded testosterone cream for men propecia bestellen forum over the counter robaxin generic name for cephalexin pharmacy has best price danazol cialis soft uk brand name effexor xr drug store online order albenza long time side effects cytotec buy inderal online canada no prescription canadian pharmacy nizoral generic depakote in lipitor india amitriptyline 25mg cost canadian health insurance cost what is neurontin 300 mg used to treat ophthacare shopping diltiazem 360 price hoodia 10 mg cost medstore canada dulcolax suppository coupons typical prednisone dosage for poison ivy accutane journal 2012 buy cheap alli pills erection probalan usa cvs prices ginette-35 for men sale in uk mentat no prescription compare prices free discount card for prescriptions can you get tricor over the counter is there a shortage of prevacid cipro tablets pictures levitra 10 mg 4 film tablet buy haldol with paypal amlodipine besylate 10mg drug market order levitra plus buy retin a micro 0.04 best pharmacy to order yasmin buy azithromycin and doxycycline seroflo generico ditropan to purchase without a prescription order tadacip pills prednisolone online cheap zenegra online meds best generic venlor review how long do i need to take plavix mirapex over counter uk buy generic raloxifene mylan generic for keppra without buy cleocin buy benicar online in usa celexa reviews is the canadian online pharmacy legitament how to buy drugs online without getting caught can you buy lincocin over the counter in germany cheap danazol sale uk hyaluronic acid injections cost in india terramycin shipping overseas can you buy viagra on ebay trandate mist canada does digoxin have generic liquid probalan review canada buy suprax without prescription is there a generic equivalent for nexium zofran injection cpt code mometasone cream for eczema astelin tablets price why is there a shortage of zoloft canadian crestor 10mg online schools pharmacy technician degree generic wellbutrin cost without insurance non persciption pyridium order cheap pain pills what are the side effects of celebrex 200 mg lotensin 10 mg tablet how to take dutas benfotiamine dose neuropathy list of tesco stores selling viagra super active lek hyzaar forte purchase propranolol inderal buy bactrim without rx buying robaxin for dogs use lanoxin coupon online cheap nike air max 95 trainers uk how to take kamagra buy protonix pills in the mexico what is paroxetine hcl 10 mg tablet buy pariet 80 mg online buy generic erythromycin online comprar cefixime online bomba de vacio disfuncion erectil biaxin with prescription arjuna in the uk propecia dose study american pregnancy association depo provera orlistat medication overnight delivery 25 mg prednisolone tablets for dogs buy cipro cialis uk buy viagra cheap mevacor 20 mg midamor from india blood pressure medicine triamterene best generic tegretol sites diovan medication coupons what is the maximum dosage for levitra buy tadacip tablets us what does fluoxetine 20 mg capsule look like ventolin generic canada cheap diflucan 200mg lloyds pharmacy opening times northampton zovirax tablets glucotrol xl from usa oxytrol uk brand name buy ponstel capsules online pharmacy no prescription tramadol levothroid online ordering generic name allopurinol aches and pains clinic first canadian can you buy malegra fxt in ireland flomax dosage strengths zenegra 100 uk what is prednisone for dogs used to treat noroxin non perscription countries cleocin refill pack doxycycline dose malaria prophylaxis www.astrazeeca.com stats 365 attendances define percocet drug how much is levitra plus tablets cheap emsam sale uk raloxifene breast cancer prevention baytril dosage for racing pigeons betneval creme 0 1 can you order kytril buy dostinex usa viagra subscribe overseas pharmacy no prescription meclizine does buspar cause weight loss or gain buy asics football boots online australia simultaneous estimation of simvastatin and ezetimibe lisinopril 20 mg cheap buy ceftin online from australia zyprexa recommended dosage buy lamictal for daily use list of tesco stores selling sinemet cardura order on web zithromax suspension dosing parlodel generic reviews where can i buy claravis online cordarone for men sale in uk can buy suhagra online what is prometrium 200 mg capsule common side effects of omnicef what does amaryllis flower mean farmaco generico dello zovirax lortab 5-500 street value advair diskus over the counter breathing can femara cause weight gain brand viagra to buy in the canada without a prescription cipro birth control online uk buy viagra tablets in manchester desyrel pills sweat common side effects of accutane can you take lynoral daily buy aleve next day generic pulmicort for sale on line paxil cr discount buying ortho tri-cyclen using paypal crushing levaquin tablets viagra blue pill from pfizer what is trileptal side effects can you buy atacand pharmacy canadian silagra drug in canada pharmacy norvasc sales 2007 medrol brand positioning metformin no prescription generic retino-a cream 0,025 weight gain ashwagandha medicine online lipothin no prescription needed how to get phenamax in australia fastest retin-a ge uk delivery ordering seroquel uk where cane you buy zovirax order ditropan pharmacy cash forum zaditor online buy prescription can we trust female cialis online keppra overnight pharmacy is it safe to order brand amoxil buy mentat ds syrup tablets online oder mg tablets of cephalexin where are crocodiles and alligators found cozaar from europe cheapest paroxetine generic prescription safe to buy generic eurax from usa is it legal to buy antibiotics online pharmacy order cephalexin 500mg online abilify lawsuit 2010 rumalaya gel tablets uses hyzaar vs cozaar 20 Purchase accutane 20mg order minocycline cheap capoten cost in canada indian erythromycin decadron order online what does a lasix tablet look like canada drug pharmacy rating finasteride 1mg generic no prescription fluoxetine uk brand name soft cialis online generic hyaluronic acid no prescription how to order plavix online how to use differin .3 gel metoclopramide mg order wellbutrin reviews for depression buy benadryl hong kong cream glucophage 500mg dosage pulmicort respules generic name permethrin cream 5 scabies research grade prazosin buy cardura online usa where can i buy prozac online buy nootropil with e check viagra side effects viagra vs cialis vs levitra cleocin gel pills drugstore exelon maximum dosage purinethol for sale uk cipla viagra review buy brand cordarone pharmacy has best price exelon messi stats this season where to decadron generic zoloft in usa para que se usa el medicamento prozac what types of rumalaya gel are there costco opening times croydon flagyl generic drug aleve coupons usa order plendil in comprar femara pela internet pfizer generic birth control recall lethal zyprexa dose how much will premarin cost what does depakote do to the brain purchase atrovent lioresal shortage cheap brahmi india emsam overnight shipping cheap where to buy lithium bromide where can i buy calan mg is atarax over the counter buy online 100 mg hytrin aricept dosage maximum motrin ib recall

Sins in the name of secularism

The narrative in which Muslims see themselves as victims of secularism has about as much validity as the Sangh Parivar’s charge of Muslim appeasement. Muslims are not victims of secularism but of a certain kind of secular politics

On the eve of the 2004 general election, held against the backdrop of the Gujarat riots, with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and its allies widely predicted to win, a group of leading South Asian scholars discussed the alarming resurgence of the Hindu Right and its implications in a book somewhat rhetorically titled Will Secular India Survive?

The authors made it clear that they did not presume to be the “arbiters of India’s secular destiny” which historian Mushirul Hasan noted would “ultimately be settled in the rural hinterland and dusty towns and not on the campuses of Delhi or at the India International Centre.” But they had an upbeat message. They believed that “India’s millions” were too deeply wedded to the idea of “pluralist co-existence” to allow any attempt to subvert it. The country’s complex cultural diversity and its long tradition of people of different faiths living together despite periods of often violent dissonance were the biggest safeguard against it becoming a “Hindu India.”

2014 and fading moderate voices

Prof. Hasan, who edited the volume, summed up their underlying message with a quote from Andre Beteille, the distinguished sociologist: “The social and political turmoil in the country does not make the case for secularism weaker, it makes it stronger. Indian intellectuals will do little good to themselves or their country if they espouse secularism in fair weather and disown it in foul weather.”


It was not exactly a fashionable view to take at a time when the supposedly better informed psephologists and media pundits were declaring game over for secular politics. In the event, though, the “ivory tower” academics proved closer to the mark as the BJP lost not only the 2004 election but also went on to lose the next one, in 2009, and its Hindutva agenda hasn’t quite recovered since.

Ten years on, an intense debate on the future of secularism is raging again in the face of an increasingly toxic election campaign in which moderate voices are struggling to be heard. One doesn’t know how those scholars would respond if they were to be asked the same question today, and most likely, secular India will survive “Modiwad” to live another day. But there is a new disturbing trend: the public discourse on secularism has hardened and become coarser (on social media sites, secularists are routinely mocked as “Sickular” and “sickularists”). More and more people across all communities see it as a failed idea and blame it for encouraging competitive sectarianism. Rather than promoting harmony and coexistence as it was intended to, Congress-style secularism is seen to have ended up as a divisive force instead.

There are echoes here of the debate on British multiculturalism which many believe has prevented ethnic minority groups from integrating into the wider society and led to cultural ghettoisation. But there is an important difference. Whereas in Britain, minority groups love multiculturalism and see it as a mark of success of their campaign for the right to preserve their cultural identity, Indian secularism is despised in almost equal measure by minorities, especially Muslims, as its traditional detractors on the Hindu Right.

Convergence of religious Right

The increasingly outspoken Muslim attacks on secularism, almost echoing the language of the Sangh Parivar, is a relatively new development. It has gone beyond murmurs of disillusionment or a show of protest against political abuses of secularism, and is now verging on a wholesale rejection of the idea of secular polity itself. There is even loose talk whether Muslims should launch a brand new party of their own to protect their interests having been “betrayed” by the Congress and other secular groups. On the face of it, the increasing convergence of the Hindu and Muslim Right on this issue might sound strange but it is no coincidence that they are singing from the same hymn sheet.

The truth is that the Muslim Right which hijacked the community’s leadership after independence was never really comfortable with the idea of secularism which it associated with anti-religiosity but found it a convenient means of advancing its own sectarian agenda. Religious issues which were of no importance to millions of ordinary Muslims were raised in the name of secularism. And if these demands were not met it was claimed that secularism had failed to deliver. It will be instructive to look at the list of Muslim “causes” espoused in the past 60-odd years and see how many of them had anything to do with the community’s “secular” interests as opposed to religious matters. The Sachar Committee’s findings are as much an indictment of the Indian state as of the Muslim leadership for failing to address the community’s problems.

The irony is that many of the Muslim leaders waxing eloquent about the failure of secularism today have been complicit in its abuse in return for official patronage. It is with their help that the Congress and groups like the Samajwadi Party were able to ply their trade in what Shahid Siddiqui, editor of Nai Duniya and former Member of Parliament has described as “electoral secularism.” Now that they are being challenged by a new generation of Muslims who want an end to the old ways of doing politics, they are trying to portray themselves as victims.

The danger of blind rage

In a way, it is just as well that secularism is rid of fair-weather friends. What is more worrying is the intensely anti-secularism mood in the wider Muslim community which feels it has been used by the secular political class to fight its own battles with Hindu nationalists. Few will quibble with that argument and the sense of frustration and anger this has generated among Muslims is understandable. But the difficulty is that they are confusing the Congress brand of distorted secularism with the idea of secularism itself. They are making the same mistake that they throw at non-Muslims who wilfully or otherwise confuse the al-Qaeda version of Islam with true Islam. The result is that in their blind rage they are in danger of throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

Secularism, let’s remember, was an important reason why so many Muslims happily chose to stay back in India and though often the ride has been bumpier than they may have expected at the time they have never regretted their decision to live in a secular state. For all its flawed implementation and abuses, the fact that there is a constitutional regime designed to give minorities protection and that there are secular laws they can invoke to seek justice are nothing to be scoffed at.

The narrative in which Muslims see themselves as victims of secularism has about as much validity as the Sangh Parivar’s charge of Muslim appeasement. At the risk of labouring the point, I repeat that they are not victims of secularism but of a certain kind of secular politics; and, more often than not, they themselves have been guilty of abetting the sins committed in the name of secularism.

If today the nation is debating threats from communalism it is because secularism matters to the vast majority of Indians. I’ve heard it said in Muslim circles that the choice of secularism was not a favour done to them, but even as “accidental” beneficiaries they should cherish it because as a minority in a Hindu-majority India, they need it more.

To undermine secularism in a fit of anger will be politically suicidal akin to turkeys voting for Christmas. Besides, nothing will please the BJP more. Secularism must be nurtured and restored to good health if only to deny its detractors the pleasure of seeing it buried.

 Source: The Hindu